10 Tips for Breaking in Your Softball Glove

A well-broken-in softball glove can make all the difference in your game, improving comfort, flexibility, and control. A stiff, new glove can be frustrating, but with the right techniques, you can speed up the process and get your glove game-ready in no time. Here are some proven tips on how to break in a softball glove effectively.

1 - Use Glove Oil or Conditioner

Applying a small amount of glove conditioner or oil helps soften the leather of baseball and softball gloves, making it more flexible. Use a soft cloth or sponge to rub it in, focusing on the pocket and laces. Be careful not to overdo it, as too much oil can weaken the gloves’ leather.

When choosing a product, look for formulas made specifically for softball or baseball gloves—avoid household oils. These conditioners are designed to interact with the glove leather and preserve durability. This step is especially important for new softball gloves that are made of thick or high-end leather requiring more break-in time.

2 - Play Catch Regularly

The best way to break in a baseball or softball glove is the traditional method of playing catch. Repeatedly catching balls will help shape the pocket and make the softball glove more responsive. Try using a softball, as it’s larger and will help mold the pocket faster.

This is the most recommended technique by coaches and experienced players because it mimics actual gameplay. Aim to use the new glove for as many throws, catches, and practice sessions as possible to form the glove to your hand.

Practice catching with a partner or against a wall. The more you use your brand new glove, the faster the glove will conform to your unique playing style.

3 - Use a Ball Mallet or Softball

If you can’t play catch right away, use a glove mallet or a softball to pound the pocket and other stiff areas. This mimics the impact of catching a ball and helps loosen up the new leather.

Working the glove with a mallet also gives you control over pocket depth and shape. To break in your glove in this method, angle the glove slightly and pound down repeatedly in the center of the pocket to form it for catching fly balls or fast grounders, depending on your position.

4 - Wrap Your Glove

When not in use, place a softball in the pocket, close the glove around it, and secure it with rubber bands or a belt. Leave it overnight or longer to help the leather form around the ball.

Many players like using this method after applying ball glove conditioner or after each catch session to set the pocket in the desired shape. Keeping a softball in the glove helps avoid flat or uneven glove structures.

5 - Steam Treatment

Many sporting goods stores offer glove steaming services, which can help soften the leather quickly. You can also do this at home by carefully steaming the glove with hot water or a damp towel in the microwave for 30 seconds. Be cautious not to overheat it, as excessive moisture can damage the leather.

Steaming works by loosening the fibers of natural leather, making it easier to mold. For safety, keep the glove dry on the outside and avoid direct contact with metal racks. This process is often used for gloves right off the shelf when time is limited before practice or a game.

6 - Flex and Work the Glove

Repeatedly opening and closing the glove helps break in the leather. You can also bend and twist the fingers to make the glove more flexible.

Flexing your glove mimics game situations where you need responsiveness and quick closure. Doing this for a few minutes each day will gradually improve glove movement and reduce stiffness.

Also, try squeezing a softball inside the glove to strengthen the pocket formation.

7 - Use a Microwave or Oven with Caution 

Some players attempt to speed up the breaking-in process by using heat sources like microwaves or ovens. While this can work, it also risks damaging the leather if done improperly. If you try this method, keep the glove in for only a short time and monitor it closely.

Use this only as a last resort. Never leave the glove unattended in the oven or microwave. Always test with low heat and remember that synthetic parts of newer gloves may react differently.

8 - Avoid Water Submersion 

Soaking your glove in water may seem like a good idea, but it can lead to long-term damage. Water can weaken the leather and stitching, reducing the glove’s lifespan. Instead, stick to conditioning and natural break-in techniques.

If your glove gets wet during a game, let it dry naturally—never use external heat, which can stiffen and crack the leather. Always apply glove conditioner afterward to restore softness.

9 - Store It Properly

Always store your glove in a cool, dry place when not in use. Keeping a ball in the pocket will help maintain its shape.

Avoid tossing your glove in your equipment bag without care. Letting it sit improperly can undo your hard work shaping it. Use a glove wrap or tie a ball inside to ensure it retains its optimal form between games. And while you're protecting your glove, don't forget to care for your gear too—storing clean, breathable softball uniforms properly helps them last longer and stay game-ready.

10 - Know Your Glove Material

All gloves are not built the same. Leather types vary in stiffness, grain, and thickness:

• - Full-grain leather gloves require more break-in time but last longer.

•  

• - Synthetic gloves are easier to break in but may not offer the same durability and feel.

•  

• - Mesh-backed gloves are lightweight and tend to break in faster.

Understanding your glove’s material helps determine how much effort or conditioning is required. Premium leather lasts years with care, so break it in right!

Gear Up for Your Next Game!

Breaking in a softball glove takes time and effort, but with patience and the right techniques, you can have a perfectly broken-in glove that feels great on the field. Stick to these tried-and-true methods, and you'll be game-ready in no time.

At Sports Gear Swag, we’ve got the custom softball apparel you need to complete your game-day look—from customizable softball jerseys to pants, stirrups, compression shirts, and more. Browse our collection today and gear up with quality and style you can count on.